Serving the Dallas–Fort Worth Metroplex CSIA Certified Licensed & Insured
24/7 Emergency Service (469) 555-0134
Chimney For DallasCHIMNEY FOR DALLASMASTER CRAFTSMAN & SERVICE

(469) 555-0134Free Estimate
Upgrades · From the rooftops of DFW

Modernizing an old brick fireplace: the before-and-after playbook

That orange-brown 1978 brick wall has exactly four futures: painted or limewashed (fast, dramatic, budget), re-faced in stone or tile (the full transformation), German-schmeared for texture-softened rustic, or, heresy to some, cleaned, repointed, and celebrated as-is with a modern mantel. Each path’s befores, afters, and the one-way doors to know about.

CSIA-certified team 4 min read

DFW’s housing boom left tens of thousands of living rooms anchored by the same wall: orange-to-brown brick, brass-era accessories, colonial mantel. Modernizing it is the most-requested single project in our remodel book, and it forks into four paths with very different commitments:

Path 1: paint or limewash (the weekend transformer)

After: crisp white/cream for farmhouse-modern, charcoal for drama, or limewash’s soft translucent age. Budget and speed: the entry tier, days not weeks. The one-way door: paint doesn’t strip off brick without restoration-grade effort, and it must never seal active moisture inside. Limewash is the semi-reversible cousin, it wears and washes back over years, forgiveness built in.

Path 2: re-face (the full metamorphosis)

After: stacked stone, large-format porcelain, or limestone floor-to-ceiling, the brick disappears entirely, the listing-photo champion. Reality: tier-2/3 budget, and the moment to handle appliance upgrades, once new stone is up, nobody’s cutting it for an insert

.

Path 3: German schmear (the texture play)

After: mortar smeared and partially wiped over the brick, softening orange into irregular European-rustic white-gray. Sits between paths 1 and 2 on cost, photographs beautifully in transitional interiors, and is genuinely permanent, mortar bonds like mortar. Commit or don’t.

Path 4: celebrate it (the contrarian winner)

After: the same brick, professionally cleaned, joints crisply repointed, paired with a massive modern cedar mantel and minimalist steel doors. Good 70s brick is honest material wearing bad accessories; sometimes the modernization is everything around it. Cheapest path, fully reversible, and increasingly the designer’s pick as painted-brick fatigue sets in.

Before any path: the two checks. (1) Moisture and structure, remodeling over problems gift-wraps them for later; every remodel of ours starts with the quick inspection. (2) Sample on your brick, paint colors and schmear density read completely differently on 1978 orange than on Pinterest’s brick, we sample a hidden square foot before you marry a finish. Start with both.
CDThe Chimney For Dallas team — CSIA-certified chimney and fireplace specialists working across the DFW metroplex. Meet the team or book a free estimate.